IS Ethan from the Pokemon games of heartgold or soulsilver from heartgold version or soulsilver version?

I want to know which of these Pokemon games Ethan is really from? heartgold or soulsilver version?IS Ethan from the Pokemon games of heartgold or soulsilver from heartgold version or soulsilver version?
Technically you can play as either Ethan or Lyra in either game. Won't make a difference. Though if, by this question, you meant what I thought you meant last time...

----

I know what you're getting at: in Firered/Leafgreen, the boy Red was for Firered, while the girl Leaf was in Leafgreen. In HGSS's intro, it shows the boy with the silver background, near the end, and the girl with gold. However, I consider Ethan to be Heartgold, while Lyra is with Soulsilver because:



1) Originally, I believe the only-playable boy character was called "Gold" and his rival "Silver." (The girl introduced as playable in Crystal was "Krystal.")

2) The pokemon special manga calls the boy "Gold."

3) Ethan has gold/yellow in his cap, whereas Lyra has none, instead a pure white-colored (silver) hat. Ethan wears more red (Ho-oh), while Lyra wears slightly more blue than red (Lugia.)
Ethan is from both, he is the playable character. He is also an updated verison of "Gold" from the original games, Gold and Silver.IS Ethan from the Pokemon games of heartgold or soulsilver from heartgold version or soulsilver version?
Ethan is available as the player character in both HGSS.IS Ethan from the Pokemon games of heartgold or soulsilver from heartgold version or soulsilver version?
I am not sure, but I think he is from pokemon Gold/heartgold

revlon lipstick